4Closure Ranch is Not Immune
4S Ranch is really not a bad place to be. It's got the good schools, it's got the parks and the trails, as well as the convenience of the recently completed Town Center.
The initial master plan circa 2001-2003 was also quite decent. Some of the lot sizes were generous, the parks aplenty, and the sidewalks nice and wide. As for the mello roos? For a 3,000 sqft home at an asking price of roughly $500,000, the 0.5% mello roos only translate to roughly $2,500 per year.
But then the builders got greedy, and by 2005 they also realized the bubble was about to burst. To fully take adventage of the inflated prices at the peak of the bubble, the builders shrunk the lot sizes, reduced the number of parks, and increased the mello roos to 0.7-0.8%. And therefore the same 3,000 sqft home, but with an asking price of $850,000, ends up with $6,400 of mello roos per year.
But the mello roos is just a small part of this madness. Middle class folks, even upper-middle class folks, simply couldn't afford $850,000 for a tract home. It is that simple.
Let's see how one owner who bought at the top is doing these days...
17068 Silver Pine Rd., San Diego, CA 92127 --5 beds, 5.0 baths, 3,628 sq ft --12/2005: purchased for $901,000 ($248/sqft)--05/2007: listed for $899,888 --Price Reduced: 06/16/07 -- $899,888 to $889,888 --Price Reduced: 07/02/07 -- $889,888 to $879,888 --Price Reduced: 07/15/07 -- $879,888 to $869,888 --Price Reduced: 08/23/07 -- $869,888 to $849,888 --Price Reduced: 09/27/07 -- $849,888 to $799,888 --Price Reduced: 10/07/07 -- $799,888 to $789,888 --Price Reduced: 10/20/07 -- $789,888 to $779,888 --Price Reduced: 11/18/07 -- $779,888 to $769,888 --Price Reduced: 11/27/07 -- $769,888 to $749,888 --Price Increased: 01/06/08 -- $749,888 to $750,000
--Price Reduced: 02/07/08 -- $750,000 to $720,000 ($198/sqft)
That's a $180,000 loss in value in slightly over 2 years, or 20% drop in value. Is it enough to entice someone to step in? I think a look at the map above (provided by Realtytrac.com) should answer that question.