Skip to Content

Dietary Fat Raises Insulin Levels

My previous post showed how high-protein foods can raise post-meal insulin levels higher than high-complex-carbohydrate foods (Beef Raises Insulin More Than Oatmeal).

This post shows how higher-fat diets raise post-meal insulin (and glucose) levels higher than lower-fat, higher-carb diets.

I'm finding more and more evidence for the benefits of eating a lower-fat, lower-protein, higher-complex-carbohydrate diet. This is not what I expected ... having read the rational for, and experimented with, low-carb Atkins-like diets.

Here's the study:
Effects Of Isoenergetic High-Carbohydrate Compared With High-Fat Diets On Human Cholesterol Synthesis And Expression Of Key Regulatory Genes Of Cholesterol Metabolism, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2001

It was a small randomized crossover study that compared:

  • High-fat diet (40% carbohydrate, 45% fat) (HF)
  • High-carb diet (55% carbohydrate, 30% fat) (HC)

And found:"During the oral-glucose-tolerance test, both glucose and insulin rose to higher concentrations after the HF diet than after the HC diet, showing lower glucose tolerance and insulin sensitivity with the HF diet."
(Insulin sensitivity was improved in the HC diet because it took less insulin to clear more post-meal glucose.)
Click for larger.Above: Plasma glucose and insulin concentrations during oral-glucose-tolerance tests performed after 3 weeks of the high-fat (•) and high-carbohydrate (о) diets. * Significantly different from the high-carbohydrate diet, P < 0.05.
Improvements in Blood Lipids

The researchers also found improvements in blood lipids with the high-carb diet - although I was just looking at insulin and glucose levels. High-carb diets will sometimes show increased triglycerides. This study did not. Researchers attributed that to greater use of complex carbs and limited simple sugars.

Lipid findings:

  • Concentrations of total cholesterol were significantly lower after the HC diet than after the HF diet.
  • Both the HDL and LDL fractions were significantly lower after the HC diet than after the HF diet. The ratio of LDL to HDL was unchanged.
  • Plasma triacylglycerol concentrations did not differ significantly between the HF and HC diets.

A curious finding of this study ...

There was, in fact, increased synthesis of cholesterol in the HC diet. That might not be surprising since eating more carbohydrate presents more of the raw material for cholesterol synthesis (acetyl CoA), as I discussed in previous posts. There was also an increase in the expression of the gene for the enzyme HMG-CoA reductase. This is the enzyme that statins inhibit. And yet, even though there was more of this enzyme, and more raw material for making cholesterol, and more cholesterol made - there was a decrease in plasma cholesterol. (Perk up, statin makers.) The authors attributed this to better clearance of cholesterol (via LDL receptor) from the blood of people eating the low-fat high-carb diet.
________

Similar entries
  • Beef Raises Insulin More Than Oatmeal

    And ...

    • Fish raises insulin more than popcorn.
    • Cheese raises insulin more than white pasta.

    This is not news. These findings appeared 11 years ago:

    An Insulin Index Of Foods: The Insulin Demand Generated By 1000-kj Portions Of Common Foods, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 1997

    Among the foods tested, breakfast cereals as a group (Cornflakes, Special K, Honeysmacks, Sustain, All-Bran, muesli, oatmeal porridge) produced a lower insulin score* than protein-rich foods as a group (beef, white fish, cheese, eggs, lentils, baked beans). Foods of equal caloric content were compared.

    * Insulin score was calculated as the area under the 120-minute insulin response curve for 1000 kJ of test food, relative to a reference food (white bread). (1000 kJ is about 240 calories.)

    A strong insulin response is not always desirable.

  • Prostate Cancer and Low-Fat Diets: 4 Studies

    Coincidentally, Tara over at the New York Times' Well Blog just posted this:
    Low-Fat Diet May Cut Prostate Cancer Risk, NYTs Well Blog, May 16 2008.

    It's based on this study:
    Effect of Low-Fat Diet on Development of Prostate Cancer and Akt Phosphorylation in the Hi-Myc Transgenic Mouse Model, Cancer Research, April 2008

    Where mice were fed:

    • High-fat diet (HF: 42% of calories from fat)

  • Diet Update

    I can't get over how low my blood sugars have been!

    Here's my story in a nut shell...

    Last summer, on a fluke, I tested my postprandial (after-eating) blood glucose (BG). It was around 140 mg/dl. I had only had some melon about 2 hours previously. I thought the reading was high. I tested it subsequently, and found both my fasting BG in the morning, and a number of after-meal tests were high ... in the range of Impaired Fasting Glucose (IFG) and Impaired Glucose Tolerance (IGT).

  • Type Of Fat Eaten Affects Insulin Levels

    This is a follow-up to my post, Dietary Fat Raises Insulin Levels.

    Warren asked:"I am curious whether there is any detail provided in these studies regarding the types of fat, or is all fat, i.e., saturated, unsaturated, etc. lumped together?"The type of fat matters. The more saturated the fat, the more often it's associated with reductions in insulin sensitivity. The following study is often cited:

    Substituting Dietary Saturated For Monounsaturated Fat Impairs Insulin Sensitivity In Healthy Men And Women: The KANWU Study, Diabetologia, 2001

  • "Can I Eat A Low-Carb Diet, But Not Eat So Much Fat?"

    This is another in my series of posts on low-carb diets. I've been reducing the amount and changing the type of carbohydrate I eat, which by default changes the amount of fat and protein I eat. I'm wondering what the long-term effect of this pattern of eating is.________

  • Thoughts On Meat And Cancer

    Some diagnoses of cancer have hit my family in the last few months. It's been a trying time. I've been especially keen to understand why, so I've been pouring over research. One dietary item keeps popping up ... meat. I don't know what it is about meat ... heme-iron, hormones, a type of fat, environmental toxins that are dissolved in animal fat, carcinogens produced via cooking, etc. But the association is common in my reading.

  • Lowering Blood Glucose The Drug-Free Way

    I've been meaning to post this for months and now is a good time, given my previous post about deaths linked to an intensive diabetes drug regimen. This study shows that diet, and diet alone, can affect a change in glycemic measures, e.g. HbA1c, that rivals what can be had with drug therapy.

    It's one of the studies Melinda mentioned in comments. I like it because it's a diet study, not a nutrient study. Diet studies are harder to conduct than nutrient interventions. But to me they're more real. They're about foods and what people eat, and how that day-to-day behavior can affect health.

  • Now You See It, Now You Don't: Liver Cancer

    Would it were that cancer in the real world could be so readily switched off.

    Here's another study. On rats. After administering a carcinogen (aflatoxin), researchers fed rats a high-protein diet. The rats' cancer grew. Researchers switched to a low-protein diet, the rat's cancer regressed. Researchers switched back to the high-protein diet. The rats' cancer came back, with a vengeance.

  • Bacteria and Blood Sugar

    Something is pushing my blood sugars down and I think it's short chain fatty acids (SCFAs), at least in part.

    Short chain fatty acids (SCFAs) are produced in the large intestine by the action (fermentation) of bacteria on undigested carbohydrates. SCFAs are absorbed through the colon wall. Those little fatty acids are in fact responsible for providing us with a few more calories from the food we eat. Just a few. Maybe accounting for about 10% of our total caloric intake 1, 2

    What Type of Carbohydrates Produce SCFAs?

  • Too sweet

    I got a call from my doctors this morning that I failed the glucose tolerance test and will have to take another one, but this one will be a 12 hour fast followed up with three blood draws spread over a three hour period. If I fail this one it means that I have gestational diabetes , which is a type of diabetes you can develop during pregnancy.
    Like the type 1 and type 2 diabetes you can get when you're not pregnant, gestational diabetes causes the glucose to stay in your blood instead of moving into your cells and getting converted to energy. Why does this sometimes happen when you're pregnant?

  • Meat

    I sure am glad it's not my job to come up with the best eating plan for all Americans, let alone the world.1 (The World Health Organization has my sympathy.) The choices and defenders of those choices are numerous and polarized.

    Regarding carbohydrates, it may be that a low-carbohydrate diet, around 10% of calories, is the best eating plan for overall health for everyone. Alternatively, it may be that a high-carbohydrate diet, above 45% of calories, is. Research has not sufficiently compared and contrasted the two.

  • Dr. Weil Weighs In On Gary Taubes' New Book

    Gary Taubes wrote Good Calories, Bad Calories. Dr. Weil liked it.

    CNN's Larry King Live presented an interview with Gary Taubes last Friday. Jimmy Moore posted Dr. Weil's portion of the interview on YouTube:

    For this segment (about 7 minutes):
    Guest Host: Joy Behar, co-host of the talk show "The View."
    Guest: Gary Taubes
    Guest: Mehmet Oz, MD
    Guest: Andrew Weil, MD

  • Dr. Ornish: "When You Go On An Atkins-Type Diet, You Lose Weight. But You Mortgage Your Health."

    This is another in my series of posts on low-carb diets. I've been reducing the amount and changing the type of carbohydrate I eat, which by default changes the amount of fat and protein I eat. I'm wondering what the long-term effect of this pattern of eating is.________
    Jimmy Moore on his Livin' La Vida Low-Carb™ Blog, posted the following YouTube of a 2002 Charlie Rose program this week.

  • Resistant Starch May Reduce Risk Of Colon Cancer

    Given the heated interest in resistant starch (RS) these days, lab rats' diets have been getting pretty darn starchy. And by the looks of it, their colons are healthier for it.

  • Reacquainting Myself With My Glycogen

    I wondered how much of the weight I lost when I reduced my carbohydrate intake this summer was a result of water loss. You may recall I was losing a pound a day without changing my caloric intake. I suspect that rate would have slowed.1 Still, I wasn't happy with the goings-on in the mirror. So I ate an apple. Then 2 tablespoons of brown rice. And an entire 1.5 oz (31 g of carbs!) box of Sunmaid raisins. OK, 2 boxes. I was on a roll, not literally.

  • I Have Prediabetes

    Or at least I thought I did. Last summer my fasting blood sugars were pushing 120 mg/dl. (100-125 is prediabetes, 126 or more is full-fledged diabetes). I went on a very low-carbohydrate, Atkins diet. My fasting sugars came down, hovering near 100.

    I went off the Atkins diet when I experienced some precancer, and when others in my family were diagnosed with cancer. I went on an animal-free, high-carbohydrate diet. Now, over 70% of my calories come from carbohydrate.* And my fasting blood sugars are always in the 70s!

  • Environmental Pollutants May Up Risk For Diabetes

    The buzz at work this week is that pesticides could increase the risk for diabetes, and insulin resistance - big time. This week's Lancet came out with a commentary highlighting the work of Dr. Duk-Hee Lee, et al. Dr. Lee's group found the odds of having diabetes were 38 times higher! for people with high blood levels of toxic persistent organic pollutants (POPs, such as dioxin and PCBs) than for people with low levels. And the association was dose dependant - the higher your levels, the higher your risk.

  • Casein and Protein Amounts in Some Dairy Foods

    Just for the fun of it, and because I've been reading studies like my previous post, I looked to see how much casein is in typical dairy foods.

    Modification of Bovine β-Casein to Improve the Characteristics and Manufacturing Properties of Cow's Milk

  • Naturally Low Cholesterol? Take Note

    Many of my ancestors came to this country less than a generation ago. (Many have yet to make the trip!) One thing I have in common with them (not a brogue, but my father could slip into his with ease) is insanely low cholesterol.

    That's why this study caught my eye:

    An Association Between Hypocholesterolaemia And Colorectal Carcinoma In An Irish Population

  • Types of Resistant Starch

    Prior to the 1980s it was thought that most starch we ate was digested and absorbed, and that those processes occurred in the small intestine. Subsequent experiments showed that portions of some starches were resistant to hydrolysis (breakdown) by our digestive enzymes. The term resistant starch (RS) was coined to describe these starches.

    Up to 75% of the starch in red kidney beans may be resistant to digestion.

  • Meat and Breast Cancer

    I've been eating a lower carbohydrate diet. By default this has me eating more meat. The recent issues of breast cancer in my family have had me investigating meat consumption's affect on cancer risk.

    I found this study while browsing the research:

    Red Meat Intake and Risk of Breast Cancer Among Premenopausal Women (November, 2006)

    Study Basics

    • Study population: 90,659 premenopausal women from the famous Nurses Health Study II

  • Meat And Cancer, Part 2

    Here was Part 1.

    I'm surprised by what I'm discovering about the possible carcinogenic effects of meat. I'm also surprised that these points weren't raised in any of the literature I read so far surrounding low-carb diets, which almost universally promote meat consumption. I've been experimenting with low-carb diets as a way to manage my blood sugar. But with the recent diagnoses of cancer in my family, I'm revisiting their safety.

  • Excessive Deaths Halt Large Government Diabetes Study

    This is a depressing story, no matter how you look at it. The government calls it a mystery.

    Study: Action to Control Cardiovascular Risk in Diabetes (ACCORD) Trial
    Population: 10,251 patients with type 2 diabetes at high risk for heart disease

    About half of those folks were assigned to an intensive BG treatment arm, the other half to a standard treatment arm.

    Intensive Treatment Goal: HbA1C < 6.0%, fasting BG 100 mg/dl or less, 2-hour postprandial BG 140 mg/dl or less
    Standard Treatment Goal: HbA1C of 7.0 to 7.9%, fasting BG of 90 mg/dl or more, postprandials not used

    After about 4 years (range: 2 to 7 years), there were 254 deaths in the intensive treatment arm and 203 deaths in the standard treatment arm ... a difference of 54 deaths ... a difference which went in the wrong direction.

  • Raspberries Ward Off Cancers Of The Gastrointestinal Tract

    Score another point for a plant-based diet!

    The American Association of Cancer Research (along with its co-sponsors and supporters, the American Cancer Society, the National Cancer Institute, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Susan G. Komen for the Cure, and the Cancer Research Prevention Foundation) held its very popular Frontiers In Cancer Prevention Research meeting last December.

    It's described as "the only comprehensive conference on cancer prevention in the world."

    I was browsing through its abstracts (hundreds) and came across a number that discussed the benefits of raspberries ... raspberries!

  • Social Influences On Diet

    A few more thoughts on why I believe social influences play a role in health and disease:

    I have a friend who has serious weight and health problems. If he was born in Abkhasia or Okinawa, would he have turned out similarly? My feeling is he wouldn't.

    By the same token, if a person from Okinawa, a place that experiences extraordinary health and longevity, were to migrate to the West, would they die earlier and experience our diseases?

    One study found they would:

    Impact Of Diet On The Cardiovascular Risk Profile Of Japanese Immigrants Living In Brazil

    Study Basics

    • Cross-sectional study
    • Participants: 234 Okinawans living in Okinawa (OO) and 160 Okinawan immigrants living in Brazil (OB) (aged 45–59 years)

    Findings

  • In case you think you're confused . . .

    I was as confused as hell today when I first read this in the New York Times, then I checked out this week's NEJM and read this (abstract only for you uncredentialed scum).

    Item One:

    For decades, researchers believed that if people with diabetes lowered their blood sugar to normal levels, they would no longer be at high risk of dying from heart disease. But a major federal study of more than 10,000 middle-aged and older people with Type 2 diabetes has found that lowering blood sugar actually increased their risk of death, researchers reported Wednesday. . . .

    Among the study participants who were randomly assigned to get their blood sugar levels to nearly normal, there were 54 more deaths than in the group whose levels were less rigidly controlled. The patients were in the study for an average of four years when investigators called a halt to the intensive blood sugar lowering and put all of them on the less intense regimen.

    Item Two:

  • NYTs Review of Gary Taubes' "Good Calories, Bad Calories"

    From a short review of Gary Taubes' new book: Good Calories, Bad Calories: Challenging the Conventional Wisdom on Diet, Weight Control and Disease in yesterday's New York Times:"As I read Taubes’s book, I kept wondering how he would deal with an obvious question. If low-carbohydrate diets are so wonderful, why is anyone fat?

  • Protein on a Vegan Diet

    Just for fun and because I was curious, I threw together a quick vegan menu to see how much protein it contained. A vegan diet excludes all forms of meat, fish, dairy products, and eggs.

    The menu below provides 60 grams of protein for 1700 calories. It does not include processed items like wheat gluten and soy-protein-based foods (veggie burgers, fake deli meats and cheeses). It even lacks wheat products, breads, tofu, and soy milk. Not saying those can't be part of a vegan diet, but I didn't want to boost the protein with anything processed.

  • Look What Eating Rachael Ray Meals Did to my Belly!

    Can you believe what those Rachael Ray recipes have done to my belly? It almost looks like I'm pregnant! Oh wait, I am pregnant! Yes, I have been keeping it a secret for awhile. I'm now at about seven and a half months and am feeling great. Scroll down to read today's post about Rachael Ray or continue reading here for more about what's up with me.

    So, what pregnancy complication could happen to someone who loves to cook (and eat) so much that she writes a blog about it? Gestational diabetes, of course! I'm pretty mad at my placenta, which creates the hormones that are blocking insulin production and raising my blood sugar levels. This means I get to test my blood sugar four times a day (yes, with the little pokey thing), eat small portions six times a day, completely avoid sugary treats, and eat a certain amount of carbs with each meal.

  • Discussion About Campbell's The China Study

    Melinda raised some points in her comment that I'm motivated to counter-comment on. It's lengthy, so I decided to post them here. The original post that she commented on was T. Colin Campbell Speaking On The Effect Of Animal Protein And Casein where I provided a link to Campbell's speech summarizing his book, The China Study.
    ________
    Melinda: