Elisberg: Cieply View Of WGA "Different Than The Reality"
Home

Elisberg: Cieply View Of WGA "Different Than The Reality"

Robert J. Elisberg, who writes the regular WGA Strike Primer columns on The Huffington Post, responds below to Michael Cieply's recent article in the New York Times entitled, Writers Strike Tests Mettle of 2 Outsiders.

Last week, Michael Cieply wrote once-again about his perception of “fissures” in the Writers Guild. It’s a theme of his. Back during the 1988 WGA strike he specialized in writing

Similar entries
  • David Blum on "The Cieply Scenario"

    We already posted our thoughts on Michael Cieply's dramatic New York Times narrative of how WGA contract negotiations got over an impasse. Now, David Blum has written a very amusing piece in the New York Press parodying Cieply's breathless style... about Michael Cieply.

    With the strike now over, there is a lot of talk about "winners and losers," most of which is premature. But pieces like

  • ROBERT J. ELISBERG'S SALUTE TO STRIKE CAPTAINS

    Robert J. Elisberg, WGA Member and contributor to The Huffington Post, wrote a piece excerpted here called, "WGA Strike Primer: Settling a Final Debt."

    It's not officially over yet, of course. There still is the matter of approving the contract. It's a 10-day process, a blink by strike standards, but long enough. Arguments of all views will be made, we do know that -- these are writers after all

  • The Endgame

    The article below was originally printed on the Huffington Post.

    WGA Strike Primer: The Endgame

    by Robert J. Elisberg

    In the beginning was the word - yet the word most heard these days in Hollywood is not about the beginning at all, but the end. What is the "endgame" to stop the strike? Ultimately, that's the only thing that matters. And with the AMPTP corporations negotiating instead with a

  • Robert J. Elisberg: Looking at the DGA Deal Memo

    Robert Elisberg continues his excellent "Strike Primer" series on HuffPo. As he points out:

    The DGA offer remains subject to analysis once the full numbers are made known. From the press release, there appear enough good and encouraging points that are highly-worth negotiating towards a settlement, and that's wonderful. But as a final offer for writers? No, there are serious problems in the

  • Lessons From 1988

    This was submitted by WGA member Robert Eisele, who was present for both the strike in 1985 and the longer strike of 1988.

    "Those who cannot remember the past are doomed to repeat it."
    -- George Santayana, 1905

    In 1988, writers endured a strike of nearly six months. In 2008, we are now approaching the halfway point of the length of that strike.

    Although most Guild members in ’88 stood strong

  • Robert J. Elisberg: AMPTP Hissy Fits and Other Tactics

    Robert J. Elisberg's latest Huffington Post column, WGA Strike Primer: Spin the Bottle, puts the latest AMPTP ploys and PR stunts into perspective. The entire piece is a must read but here are some highlights...

  • Michael Russnow: Let's Have a Formula That Is Meaningful

    Former WGAw board member Michael Russnow has been covering the strike on his personal site and recently began blogging "The Writers Strike for Dummies" on the Huffington Post. In his most recent entry, Russnow discusses the importance of setting precedents for compensation on the Web. We believed the AMPTP when they cajoled us to accept the cable deal in 1981 with the understanding that when they

  • Joan Didion's Essay On The 1988 Strike

    In 1988, Joan Didion wrote an essay on the writers' strike. There's a link to a pdf version at los angeles daze -- it's a must-read.

    Agree or disagree with how this strike has been waged, she puts her finger on realities that sound eerily familiar, 20 years later -- and on some key differences as well.

    Most importantly, the Union Blues writers that she talks about, who broke the back of the '88

  • What Fi-Core Really Means

    This was submitted by WGA member Michael Seitzman, who is currently blogging on Huffington Post as well.

    I read news today of Writers Guild member John Ridley's decision to go Financial-Core to protest the Writers Guild strike. I was angry and dismayed and my original post on the issue was full of that vitriol. I thought an edit was in order so as not to let the message to get lost in a war of

  • United Hollywood Live

    United Hollywood Live (12pm Pacific/3pm Eastern) will be joined by Robert J.

  • WGA Members Vote to End Strike

    This was sent out today by the WGA:

    LOS ANGELES and NEW YORK – The membership of the Writers Guild of America, West (WGAW) and the Writers Guild of America, East (WGAE) today voted overwhelmingly in favor of lifting the restraining order and ending their 100-day strike that began on Nov. 5. 3,775 writers turned out in Los Angeles and New York to cast ballots or fax in proxies, with 92.5% voting

  • Fact Checking the NYT

    While it's flattering that the New York Times would try to bestow such importance on Ms. Kalogridis and -- ahem -- "her friends," Michael Cieply's breathless account misses something obvious. A strike does not come to a possible (repeat, "possible") ending thanks to one person or even one website, no matter how awesome the website. The outcome of a strike is determined by the strikers. By the