Skip to Content

Misfit McCabe by L K Gardner-Griffie

Review first published at Front Street Reviews.

Stars: ****

Katie McCabe is a 14 year old girl who wants to be known for who she is and not by the McCabe family name. Katie lives with her dad, the sheriff of their town. Katie is a bit of a rebel. She is always getting into trouble with her friend Timmy but after they accidently set fire to a shed, Katie’s life just keeps going downhill.

At the beginning of the book is a Cast of Characters. This is unsual in a novel but if done right, can be helpful when a book has more than a few main characters. My only qualm with Gardner-Griffie’s Cast of Characters is that a little too much information is revealed. It doesn’t ruin the ending of the book, just tells a little about what’s going to happen.

I enjoyed reading Misfit McCabe. At first I wasn’t sure I’d enjoy it but I was wrong. The plot is well written and left open for a sequel although I’m sure the author would have done one by now if she intended to. I found myself emphasizing with Katie when she felt judged because of her name or when her family didn’t trust her but I also felt anger and frustration when she made poor choices. I think as a mother I imagined myself as her parent and how I would feel if Katie were my daughter.

There was one part that I felt a little unsure about. Katie expresses feelings for her male cousins. While I’m sure it’s common to feel attracted to cousins at first, her constant comments about it made me feel uneasy. I also found myself feeling angry at Katie’s father. I disagreed with some parts of his decision.

The author chose to include not only what Katie and the others were saying but also Katie’s thoughts. While in some books, personal thoughts are written in italics or in brackets or with the preface, “I was thinking…”, Gardner-Griffie chose to just put her thoughts in the text, right after what she says out loud. You might think that would be confusing but it’s not. What is said out loud is in quotations so unless you are speed reading, you will know the difference.

Since this book was self-published with the assistance of Lulu the front cover isn’t professionally done. While this isn’t necessarily a bad thing, I will admit that the front cover did turn me off a bit. It’s not really poorly done, but it could have been better. Also I think the blurb on the back cover should have said more.The book did a good job of keeping me interested and in making me feel like the characters were real. The emotions I felt while reading prove that.

The only thing I can think of that would have made the story better was to elaborate more at the end. I find myself wanting to know more about how life was like for Katie at the end. However the ending is complete. It doesn’t leave you hanging or anything.

Similar entries
  • These are the books I finished January 2008 along with some stats.

    Persian Girls by Nahid Rachlin
    The Rabbi's Girls by Johanna Hurwitz
    Julia's Mending by Kathy Lynn Emerson
    The Slave Dancer by Paula Fox
    The Fab Girls Guide to Friendship Hardship
    The Daring Game by Kit Pearson
    Misfit McCabe by L.K. Gardner-Griffie
    Anastasia At Your Service by Lois Lowry
    The No-Cry Sleep Solution by Elizabeth Pantley
    Smart-opedia by Maple Tree Press

    Total Books: 10
    Total Pages: 1822

    Fav Book: Smart-opedia
    Least Fav: Julia's Mending

  • Stars: ****

    I recieved this book from MotherTalk.

    I asked to review this book because I’ve been intrigued by life in Muslim countries. I’ve read other books on Muslim culture so I asked to review this one.

  • Stars: ****

    I received this book to review from Tundra Books.

    Summary: When 14 year old Neil’s uncle Chester dies, Neil is lonely. At his uncle’s cremation, he hears thumping in the coffin just as it’s put into the flames. Could Uncle Chester be alive? So Neil starts an investigation. A disembodied voice in an old stable tells him that Chester’s passing is not the only mysterious death in town, Neil along with his friend Graham work to get to the bottom of what’s happening.

  • Stars: ****

    I received this book from Multnomah Books and I wanted to review it for Mother’s Day but I didn’t get to finish it in time.
    Rattled is a Christian Parenting book for soon-to-be-moms and new-moms. I’m not Christian but I can’t say no to a parenting book so I wanted to take a look at this. Have survived two baby’s first years I feel I am qualified to determine if this book would be helpful to a new mom. Certainly, as a mom of 4, Trish Berg is qualified to write a book about parenting.

  • Stars: ****1/2
    I received a copy of this book for review. I also read it for the Pub in '08 challenge.

    Summary: In “My Soul to Keep,” Dylan Foster is once again caught in a bizarre and twisted chain of events. A parent’s worst nightmare comes true and a birthday party that should be filled with joy is turned awry when a little boy close to Dylan’s heart is snatched from a local park. With little evidence to point the way, local law enforcement is led through a chain of mystifying events that seem to go no where. With the help of an intuitive six-year-old girl who is eerily connected to the missing boy, Dylan follows a path of tantalizing clues to the truth. With the sinister presence of Peter Terry never far behind, Dylan is led to a place she never expected – or wanted – to go.

  • Stars: **1/2

    Willie’s Dad is a picture book for children who have parents in Prison. Willie is a five year old boy whose father has been in prison almost his whole life and who will be there until he’s a grown man. Willie and his Mother don’t visit his Father very often and when they do, they go with Duane, who is growing attached to Willie’s mom. His father makes a selfless decision and tells Duane to go ahead and marry the mother because Willie needs a dad and he’s a good man.

    The story is pretty good and it’s nice to see a book for children on a subject not often seen. Unfortunately there are quite a few children who have a parent in prison and who could use this book.

  • Stars: ****

    I was interested in reading this book ever since I first read a review of it. I’ve seen so many reviews for it since that I can’t remember where I first saw it! I finally was able to fit time in to read it for the Bibliography challenge and Book Around the World challenge and I’m glad I did.

  • Stars: *****

    I recieved this book for review from Random House.
    Wow. Received for review and I’m so glad. This is similar to A Far Cry From Home but mostly the story of one girl instead of many. I have not read Girlbomb which is the author’s story of herself homeless.

  • The Wentworths, by Katie Arnoldi

    The Wentworths features some of the worst human beings I’ve encountered in a long time. They aren’t evil dictators or serial rapists or junkie pedophiles. No, they’re worse -- they're super-rich L.A. snobs. However, I maintain their position at the bottom of the human pile because they’re so insidiously common, and one feels as though a Wentworth or two lurks on every street in the country – at least in the more affluent neighborhoods, that is. Each Wentworth takes douchbaggery up a notch, as if they’ve all secretly agreed to see who can make the biggest case for compulsory euthanasia.

  • As a member of Bonnie's Book Buddies, we chose Mary Lawson's book as our October read. For this review and probably for future reviews, I've stolen a format from Dewey at Hidden Side of a Leaf. Thanks Dewey!!

    The Title & Author of the book? The Other Side of the Bridge by Mary Lawson

    Fiction or Non-Fiction? Genre? Fiction

  • Stars: *****

    I received this book for review. It was also read for the Pub in 08 and In Their Shoes challenge.

  • Stars: ***1/2 These books were read for the Decades 08 Challenge and as part of the A Novel Challenge Mini-Challenge 2008.

    Alice in Wonderland was first published in 1865 and Through the Looking Glass was first published in 1871. However I read a 2006 edition by Parragon Publishing in the UK. It’s a part of the Children’s Classic Collection. (not the cover pictured)

    This was the first time I’d ever read these books, which I thought were one book, but I did know the storyline from the movie. Although I liked the movie, I wasn’t as fond of the book. Since the majority of what happens in the story is nonsense, it can be hard to follow so the movie made it a little easier. I’m not real fond of either though. They are well written and very creative, but just a little too strange for me.

  • Stars: ***1/2

    This book was read for the Casual Reading Challenge and the Back to History Challenge.

    This story takes place in 1887. Julia, who used to live in a city apartment with her grandmother and had her dressed made by private dressmakers and servants to make her food is sent to live with her country cousins on a farm. She hates everything about the farm and her cousins and is so wrapped up in her misery that when she breaks her leg, she feels totally trapped. There is nothing to do except get to know her cousins better. Maybe they aren’t as bad as she thought.

  • Stars: *****
    This review is part of a Blog Tour by Multnomah Books. I also read it for the Pub in 08 Challenge.

    Summary: When a man turns up dead in a teddy bear costume, Ginger and the other ladies of the Bargain Hunters Network learn a lesson about trusting in God rather than in wealth as they try to solve the crime and clear one of their own

    First of all, I gotta say, that when I got the offer to review this book, I had a good laugh. After all, how often is it do hear a book title like this one? There was no way I could say no to this one, I just HAD to know what it was all about. I’m sure glad I did say yes because I relished every moment I was reading this book.

    It’s not too often you have such humour mixed in with a murder mystery. I could definitely see the two being mixed in such a way that detracts from the book but Sharon Dunn put them together spectacuarly.

  • Stars: *****

    This is the first audio book I’ve ever heard/read. I listened to it on my ipod mini as I walked to and from playgroups and the library with my kids. I’ve always been wary of audio books for two reasons. 1. I didn’t think they were really reading, that they didn’t count. 2. I didn’t think I could follow it.

  • Stars: **** This book was read for the Celebrate the Author challenge.

    Celebrate the Author Note:
    Dr. Seuss is one of my favourite children’s authors so I didn’t want to cheat and just re-read some of his books that I’ve read a million times. So I decided I’d read a few of this books I haven’t read yet as well as a book about his life.

    This book is the second book Dr. Seuss ever wrote. It was published in 1938. It’s one of the longer ones, for ages 6 and up. It’s the story of Bartholomew Cubbins, a poor country boy, who removes his hat for the King only to find another hat in it’s place. Each time he takes a hat off, an identical one magically appears on his head. He is arrested and brought to the King’s Throne Room where many people try to get his hat off, to no avail. Will they ever stop coming?

  • Stars: *****

    I read this book for the Bibliography challenge.

    I'm glad I found and read this book. Dunning is a great author and I thoroughly enjoyed his writing. Reading about buying and reselling books was very interesting and makes me want to learn more about it so I can make some money finding good deals. There is some really good information on the hobby too, not just a passing mention. The way the book is written, it could almost pass as a memoir. It all sounds so real, I kept having to remind myself it wasn't.

    The story was very intriguing. The plot was well thought out. I had trouble stopping reading for the night

  • Review first posted to Front Street Reviews

    Stars: ***1/2

    Summary: Charlie Bird, The Best Bird Ever is a children’s book about a small parrot named Charlie. It highlights his life with his “featherless flock” Sara, and Molly. He is a very mischievous little bird, who is constantly proding entertainment for Sara and Molly. There is another element to the book. Charlie befriends four wild birds. He and Rusty, the ring leader of the wild birds, decide to trade places. This leads to surprising adventures for both birds.

    Charlie Bird, The Best Bird Ever is a children’s book about a small parrot named Charlie. It highlights his life with his “featherless flock” Sara, and Molly. He is a very mischievous little bird, who is constantlyproviding entertainment for Sara and Molly. There is another element to the book. Charlie befriends four wild birds. He and Rusty, the ring leader of the wild birds, decide to trade places. This leads to surprising adventures for both birds.

  • Okay . . . picture this (really) worst-case scenario: It’s cold and raining, your boyfriend/girlfriend has just dumped you, you’ve just been fired, the pile of unpaid bills is sky-high, your beloved pet has recently died, and you think you’re coming down with a cold. All you want to do (other than hiding under the covers) is to curl up with a good book, something warm and comforting that will make you feel better.
    What do you read?

  • Stars: ****1/2I read this book for the Celebrate the Author challenge and the Reading My Name challenge.

    Celebrate the Author Note:
    Dr. Seuss is one of my favourite children’s authors so I didn’t want to cheat and just re-read some of his books that I’ve read a million times. So I decided I’d read a few of this books I haven’t read yet as well as a book about his life.

    This book is a Children’s Non-Fiction book about he early life of Dr. Seuss, before he was known as that. It explains who he was as a boy and how he came to be an author and artist. The story itself is written like a picture book and ends when he is 22 and his writing life is taking off. After that is an explanation of how he came up with the idea for some of his books as well as information on his life after 22 such as when he was married and how The Cat in the Hat and Green Eggs and Ham were the result of bets by his publisher.

  • Stars: ****

    This book was read for the Reading the Author challenge.

    This one was better although I still think I liked A Brief Darkness better. It’s hard to say, they are so different. This one is actually a Newbery Honor book, National Book Award finalist and an ALA Notable Book.

  • Stars: ****

    I received this book for review from Multnomah in honour of Mother’s Day. I also decided to use it for my Themed Challenge and Pub 08.

    This is the first time I’ve seen a self-help book that is for a specific generation. Technically I’m not a Gen Xer but I’m close enough that I was interested in what this had to say. According to the introduction, a Gen Xer was born from 1960-1980 and a Millennial was born from 1980-2000. I was born 1983 but my brother was born 1977.

    Anyways, this book is also Christian Non-fiction so it covers the challenges and blessings of marriage for Generation X Christians. As I’ve stated before, I’m not Christian either but I am spiritual and believe in deity so I just took most of what was said about religion in a loose way to fit it to my needs. However there was one chapter that I just couldn’t agree with or fit to my life and it wasn’t the Church Service or Growing in God chapter. I will get to that but first, a synopsis of the chapters:

  • Stars: *****

    I chose this book because I picked it up at a library sale but I’m 95% sure I’ve actually read this once before. This is also the first 5 Star book of 2008. (Even thought it's not the first 5-star review posted.) I also read this for the Casual Reading Challenge.

    It’s the story of Lauren and her friend Andrea who both feel too fat and want to lose weight. Only Andrea takes it too far. It’s the story of Anorexia and a teen girl’s pressure to be thin. It’s told very well and I think it would be the perfect book to read along with your teen and discuss. I think if more parents discussed this book with their teens, we might make teens more aware of anorexia and the warning signs.
    I HIGHLY recommend this book to all teen girls ages 12 and up.

  • Stars: ***1/2

    This book is the 1992 winner of the Canadian Library Association Young Adult Book Award.

    Summary: The daughter of an apothecary and the owner of a secret book of healing arts, Urusla is determined to become a great heler – but her ambition makes her an outsider in the Holy Roman Empire. When she is accused of witchcraft and sentenced to burn at the stake, she is given one chance to save herself: she must march in the People’s Crusade to the holy city of Jerusalem. Along with her father and her friend Bruno, Urusla joins thousands of other pilgrims on a harrowing journey, which will expose the dark side of the “glorious” Crusades, and change her life forever.

  • Stars: *****

    This book was read for the Reading the Author challenge.

    I had major Deja Vu when reading this book. I think I may have read it before but I couldn't remember what happened before it happened so if I did, it was many years ago. This is the first Richard Peck I've ever read and I loved it.

  • I stopped off at a shop yesterday morning, on the drive back, and had a very surreal moment. My book was there on one of the shelves and just as I walked past, a woman came along, took it down from the shelf and after reading the back cover went off to buy it. I couldn't believe it. What are the chances of that happening? Not only of actually having a book up there in the first place, but actually standing there as someone takes it down and goes off to buy it. For a moment I was stunned. I immediately picked up another book and pretended to be reading, but when she turned out of sight I actually walked off after her. It was Monday morning and there was hardly anyone about and I found myself wanting to whisper 'thank you for buying my book,' or just to tell her that it was my book she had in her hands, wanting to say something, anything... Because what are the chances of seeing that again. Of course I didn't. But it was a very strange moment.

  • Stars: ***1/2

    Summary: The only witness to a tragedy loses her memory and an innocent may be in prison for the crime. Whale Song asks the difficult questions: which is the higher morality - love or law?

    I wasn't sure what to expect from this book other than there would be whales in it. The summary above comes from the back of the book and doesn't say much. I'll tell you a little more about the book so you can properly decide if it's your kind of book but don't worry, I'd never reveal too much or spoil and ending.

    The main character is an 11 year old girl whose family moves to a small town where most of the inhabitants are Native Canadians. The book is Children's Fiction but for older children, say 12 and up. A large portion of the book has stories, myths and history of Native Canadians, specifically Huuayaht. I found this very interesting.

  • This review is part of the Mother Talk Blog Tour.

    Stars: *****

    The Daring Book for Girls was written because the authors felt it was necessary to have a kind of companion book to The Dangerous Book for Boys by Conn and Hal Iggulden.

  • I received this book to review along with two giveaway copies. Details on giveaway at end of the review!

    Stars: ****

  • How much do reviews (good and bad) affect your choice of reading? If you see a bad review of a book you wanted to read, do you still read it? If you see a good review of a book you're sure you won't like, do you change your mind and give the book a try?

    In general I'd say that reviews have some affect on my choice of reading, but not terribly much because what you like and what you don't like is really a matter of taste. A reviewer could say absolutely wonderful things about a book, but I might not enjoy reading it. Similarly, I might love a book that a reviewer thought was horrible.