Skip to Content

Collected Stories by Gabriel Garcia Marquez


Title: Collected Stories
Author: Gabriel Garcia Marquez
ISBN: 0-14-015756-5
Publisher: Penguin Books Ltd/1996
Pages: 292
rating: 2.5/5

Marquez is one author, I love to read. However, I need a lot of time in between his books. I picked this after a very long time. It is a collection of twenty six short stories (originally published in three volumes, Leaf Storm and Other Stories, No One Writes to the Colonel and Other Stories, and Innocent Erendira and Other Stories). A few I had read before in another of his book, Innocent Erendira. These are given in chronological order of their publication.

Marquez won the Nobel Prize in 1982. I do not think, he needs any introduction. However, what most of us get, is to read his translated works as he wrote in Spanish. That is a disadvantage, I think.

This book has three parts and shows us the growth of Marquez as a writer. I found the initial stories not too good. I just could not relate to those. At some instances, I had to re-read and that did not help me a bit. I found it confusing, confounded and disappointed. The Third Resignation is about a seven year old boy who falls into a coma and grows to adulthood in a coffin mother’s house. The Other Side Of Death has shades of a Allan Poe nightmare.

There Are No Thieves In This Town is about man who steals three billiard balls from a pool hall and finally is foolish about the whole thing. One Of These Days is about a corrupt mayor. Dialogue With The Mirror is incomprehensible. Eyes Of A Blue Dog is a story in a dream which speaks of a doomed relationship between two people who know each other only in dream, and not in the real world.

In The Sea of Lost Time, the island is pervaded with the fragrance of roses in the sea. The smell triggers changes on the island and thats about it, as colonial misdeeds still continue. The Monologue Of Isabel Watching It Rain In Macondo is about a town wholly destroyed by incessant rain. In The Handsomest Drowned Man In The World children playing by the sea see a corpse approaching them. The women go ga-ga over him and men are jealous of him. He is named Esteban and a whole myth is built around him, Then, after a proper funeral, he is thrown back into the sea.

In Eva Is Inside Her Cat, Eva is a spirit who can take over any living thing. She is an unbalanced being and the story can be interpreted as consequences of oppression to the mind, or soul. Only part that redeems the book is the novella Innocent Erendira, which I had read before. The novella is a very poignant rendering about Erendira, who is only fourteen when we first meet her and is punished by her grand mother in a very diabolical manner when she accidentally burns her grand mother’s house. The way Erendira has to repay is heart rending. She runs away numerous times only to be brought back..

I know I will continue reading Marquez. However, this book left me wanting more. I can't even mention how a few stories were not worth reading. I just left those halfway through. Here I found, Marquez has got repetitive in his symbolism and in a few instances, the stories do not make any kind of sense. For light readers, it is strictly a no-no!

Similar entries
  • I have listed the Nobel Laureates and their books I have read so far. I have not reviewed all of those on my blog as I read a few, long time back. If I do, I will link those here. I am in the process of reading another book by Steinbeck, three by Marquez and one by Orhan Pamuk.

    1907 - Rudyard Kipling
    Jungle Book

  • There are too many books piled up on my book shelves waiting to be read. Hence I joined From the Stakes Winter Reading Challenge. That way I can read atleast 5 books from that pile from Nov 1, 2007 to Jan 30, 2008.

    My tentative list:

    Roots by Alex Haily

    The Name of the Rose by Umberto Eco

    Love in the Time of Cholera by Gabriel Garcia Marquez

    Nineteen Minutes by Jodi Picoult

    Second Glance by Jodi Picoult

    Deep Freeze by Lisa Jackson

  • I think I am getting cold feet looking at my own list. However, I have to do this. I can't go on procastinating!

    Man Booker Challenge 2008

    1) 2007 The Gathering by Anne Enright
    2) 2006 *The Inheritance of Loss by Kiran Desai
    3) 2000 *The Blind Assassin by Margaret Atwood currently reading it
    4) 1981 *Midnight's Children by Salman Rushdie
    5)
    6)

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

  • Title: Twelve Read Herrings
    Author: Jeffrey Archer
    ISBN: 0006490484
    Publisher: HarperCollinsPublishers/1994
    Pages: 324

    At one time, I used to read Jeffrey Archer like crazy. I do like the way he writes. I won't call those masterpieces, nonetheless, his books hold interest.

  • 1. How did you come across your favorite author(s)? Recommended by a friend? Stumbled across at a bookstore? A book given to you as a gift?

    2. Was it love at first sight? Or did the love affair evolve over a long acquaintance?

  • In this week I could manage to review only one book, that too a Tintin one, The Lake of Sharks. Comic books take less time to read and review. A new house entails a lot of work. Although I am nicely enconsed in my new home, all those paperwork for banks etc has to be completed. In India, nothing gets done by telephone or the internet. One has to go there and get things done.

  • What’s your favorite book that nobody else has heard of? You know, not Little Women or Huckleberry Finn, not the latest best-seller . . . whether they’ve read them or not, everybody “knows” those books. I’m talking about the best book that, when you tell people that you love it, they go, “Huh? Never heard of it?”

  • Kristin Gorski of "Write now is good" has tagged me for this.

    10 signs that I have written a book:

    1). It is set in, of all places, Australia. Frankly I don't know, why. I have never been there. However, I would like to write a book set in Australia.

    2). It is about a man lost in the forests trying to find his way out. He can talk to animals and commune with trees. He is not your macho man.

    3). No fairy tale like endings. Our man will cry when he is hurt.

    4). There is lot of internal dialogues. Symbolism is must.

    5). It would be a third person account. I cannot write in first person.

  • Books and films both tell stories, but what we want from a book can be different from what we want from a movie. Is this true for you? If so, what’s the difference between a book and a movie?

    How can one even think of comparing books and movies? Both are entirely different mediums. I am not much of a movie person. I seldom even watch a movie. I prefer reading anyday. When a book is made into movie, no doubt it gets better publicity, lot more people watch it then reading the book. However, I find most of the movies that have been adapted from a book, leave me wanting more. In a book, everything is happening inside your mind. You form certain opinions about certain characters. I would rather escape the world reading a book than watching a movie. Most of the times, I get distracted from a movie but not while reading a book.

  • "What's In A Name?" Reading Challenge
    Dates: January 1, 2008 through December 31, 2008
    The Challenge: Choose one book from each of the following categories.

    1. A book with a colour in its title.

  • I have taken this negative meme from Dewey's blog. I thought I would give it a shot. My answers are not as good as hers! Feel free to do this meme and credit it to Dewey!


    1. When you dislike a book, do you say so in your blog? Why or why not?

    I do say so. As I spend a lot of time reading and analysing it, I do think I should mention the negative aspects too. However, I mention it why I did not like that particular book. There might be cultural reasons too. Some books simply do not work for me.

    2. Do you temper your feelings about books you didn’t like, so as not to completely slam them? Why or why not?

  • I did not read a single book this last week. I am in the middle of a few books but finished none. Infact, I read very little. I did not even visit the book fair which is an yearly affair. I always look forward to it.

    I do not know why but did not feel like doing anything which consisted of books. I suppose I needed the break. I wrote a hell lot of poetry. I listened to music, watched two stupid movies and slept. Completely relaxed.

    It felt good.

  • _________________________________________________________

    What with yesterday being Halloween, and all . . . do you read horror? Stories of things that go bump in the night and keep you from sleeping?

    I thought about asking you about whether you were participating in NaNoWriMo, but I asked that last year. Although . . . if you want to answer that one, too, please feel free to go ahead and do both, or either, your choice!
    ________________________________________________________


  • Title: The Bonesetter's Daughter
    Author: Amy Tan
    ISBN: 0-8041-1498-6
    Publisher:Ballantine Books/2001
    Pages: 403

  • * When somebody mentions “literature,” what’s the first thing you think of? (Dickens? Tolstoy? Shakespeare?)
    * Do you read “literature” (however you define it) for pleasure? Or is it something that you read only when you must?

    "Literature" means classics, in most cases. Those books which are timeless and are full of substance. Most tend to think of literature as heavy reading. Not necessarily so. Lewis Caroll's Alice in Wonderland qualifies as a classic and IS a great piece of literature. And no one can call it as serious! I do not think classics are difficult to read unless one gets the gist of those. They do tell us about an era otherwise forgotten. Isn't that what literature is supposed to do?

  • Title: Down to a Sunless Sea---Short Stories
    Author: Mathias B. Freese
    ISBN: 9781587367335
    Publisher: Wheatmark/2007
    Pages: 134

    Mathias B. Freese offered me this book for reviewing and I gladly accepted it. It is a collection of 15 stories and fairly a thin book. I wouldn't call it an easy read. One needs to concentrate while reading. The mind deviates and one has to go back.

  • Every day when I wake up I ask myself the same question, "Is today going to be it?". Then I think about the date and think about how it sounds as baby's birthday. So here I am on March 26th still asking, "Is today going to be it?". I at least got a good long stretch of sleep last night and a good morning nap today. I have nothing more exciting than dishes and towels to be put away and carpet to be vacuumed. My mom bought her plane tickets today for coming to Texas a week from Sunday. I think everyone is thinking this little guy doesn't plan to come out of his own free will : )

    Tigers won against Houston, 10-9 yesterday. Today they play the Pittsburgh Pirates... Arrrrr

  • 1. Snow is fun until Christmas but then I am ready for it to melt.
    2. I'm looking forward to things slowing down just a wee bit so I can enjoy time with friends and family.
    3. Books are the best present ever! (Just in case my family is reading!) ;)
    4. One of my favorite old tv shows is M*A*S*H .
    5. I'm done with maternity clothes?!? (First thing that came to mind, sorry)

  • I stole yet another Meme from the Literary Feline!! Thanks again, this one is fun!!

    The basic facts:
    Who is your significant other? Paul
    How long have you been together? 6.5 years (married 3.5)
    Dating/Engaged/Married? Married
    How old is your Significant Other? He is 7 months older than I am. And he never lets me forget it!
    Which one:
    Who eats more? I do right now because I'm pregnant and he's on a diet lol
    Who said "I love you" first? I can't remember, but I'm pretty sure it was him
    Who sings better? I do.
    Who's older? He is.

  • How much do reviews (good and bad) affect your choice of reading? If you see a bad review of a book you wanted to read, do you still read it? If you see a good review of a book you’re sure you won’t like, do you change your mind and give the book a try?


  • Title: Neverwhere
    Author: Neil Gaiman
    ISBN-13: 9780380789016
    ISBN-10: 0380789019
    Publisher: HarperTorch/1997
    Pages: 370

  • Have you ever fallen out of love with a favorite author? Was the last book you read by the author so bad, you broke up with them and haven’t read their work since? Could they ever lure you back?

    I can name many authors. I used to read a lot of Ludlums. But I have not done it for a long time now. His latter books seems boring and repetitive. Same is the case with Alistair Maclean. Grisham too I cannot read now. In classics, I cannot read Jane Austen now. I fall asleep although I have committed to read at least two Austens for a challenge!

    Instead of authors, I would say I can't read certain genres like run of the mills mysteries bore me. Romances without stories too cannot hold my interest. I cannot read too much of sex scenes with vampires, werewolves, monsters. That puts me off completely.

    I thing it depends a lot on mood and time too. What we loved in our younger days might bore us to death now. And vice versa. In a way , one can suppose that our reading changes with age.

  • As it was BAFAB week from Jan 1-7, I bought books for my nephews, nieces and friends. I donated 50+ assorted books to an old age Home. I suppose I was just plain lucky to win three books I had put my name for. Thanks Melody, Dewey and Rhinoa. I look forward to read those. "The Road" was a coveted one!

    The Road by Cormac McCarthy from Melody's Reading Corner
    Thirteen Reasons Why by Jay Asher from Dewey

  • Scenario: You’ve just bought some complicated gadget home . . . do you read the accompanying documentation? Or not?
    Do you ever read manuals?
    How-to books?
    Self-help guides?
    Anything at all?

    Anything I get, I do read the accompanying manuals. Very thoroughly. That really makes me understand the workings of it better. I even look at the circuits too. (*I have to as I do not have a husband to help me through!)

  • Title: Downsizing Your Home With Style
    Author: Lauri Ward
    ISBN: 978-0-06-117097-3
    Publisher: Collins/2007
    Pages: 164 Hardcover

  • The Worst

    Luckily, there wasn't any real stinkers in the books I read this year. However, I was frustrated with a few. I wasn't impressed with Moll Flanders but I can't fault it since it was a product of it's time. Anyway, here are the awards for the Worst.

  • This week’s theme: Choose a political or social issue that matters to you. Find several books addressing that issue; they don’t have to be books you’ve read, just books you might like to read. Using images (of the book covers or whatever you feel illustrates your topic) present these books in your blog.